Citizen Assembly South Tyneside (CAST) Logo

The argument for (and against) safe drug taking spaces

Colin Davis

September 2022

A couple of months ago I had an argument with my teenage daughter, nothing unusual there, but this one was a bit different - she actually got me thinking that I might need a little bit of a rethink!


They'd been discussing safe drug taking spaces at uni then came home and proceeded to 'enlighten' me and her mam on the merits of such facilities. I'll be honest, I hadn't really given the issue a lot of thought but I didn't think the idea of giving junkies a place to shoot up with illegal substances was the best.

So what made me think they might be workable?


Apparently, these places are legal in Australia, Canada and a couple of countries in Europe and, although appeals for official β€˜consumption rooms’ were rejected by the UK government, there’s a drug consumption van in Glasgow where addicts can inject their substance of choice.


So, I did a bit of research (on the quiet so she wouldn’t know that she’d made me think about it!) and I found these arguments:

  • a lack of safe spaces could lead to more people dying of overdoses on the street
  • addicts, especially women, feel safer using these places as opposed to those injecting in the street who often face the threat of violence, sexual harassment and rape
  • they might cut the spread of disease because people can get clean needles etc.
  • they could be a stepping-stone to treatment and healthcare


I'm still not 100% convinced that they're a good idea - I wouldn't want one where we live because I still think that they might encourage drug use and cause crime in the local area but I guess I'm more open to at least talking about a problem that affects a lot of people in our borough…and maybe that was the whole point of the argument?